Can I Use Toys As Rewards During Training Sessions?

Please note that this article may contain affiliate links, and that means that I may earn a commission if you buy something. Read my full disclosure here.

When it comes to training sessions, many pet owners wonder whether it’s acceptable to use toys as rewards. The thought of incorporating playtime into training can be enticing, but is it effective? In this article, we will explore the pros and cons of using toys as rewards, and whether they can truly enhance your training sessions with your furry companion.

Can I Use Toys As Rewards During Training Sessions?

Benefits of Using Toys as Rewards

Increased motivation

Using toys as rewards can greatly increase your motivation during training sessions. Toys are often seen as a fun and exciting incentive, making you more eager to participate and learn. The prospect of receiving a toy as a reward at the end of a successful training session can give you the extra push needed to stay focused and committed to the task at hand.

Enhanced focus

Toys have the power to enhance your focus during training sessions. By using toys as rewards, you create a clear goal for yourself to work towards. The anticipation of receiving a toy can help you maintain concentration and block out distractions. This heightened focus allows you to absorb information more effectively and improve your overall training performance.

Positive association

One of the key benefits of using toys as rewards is the positive association they create. When you consistently associate toys with positive experiences, such as successful training outcomes, you develop a positive attitude towards the training process. This positive association not only increases your motivation but also strengthens your bond with your trainer or owner, creating a more enjoyable and rewarding training experience for both parties.

Variety and engagement

Toys offer a wide range of variety and engagement in training sessions. By incorporating different types of toys into your training routine, you can keep things interesting and prevent boredom. This variety stimulates your mental and physical agility, making the training sessions more engaging and enjoyable. Additionally, playing with different toys can help you develop a diverse skill set and adapt to various training scenarios.

Suitable Toys for Training

Interactive toys

Interactive toys are an excellent choice for training sessions. These toys often require your active participation and problem-solving skills, keeping you engaged and mentally stimulated. Examples of interactive toys include puzzle toys and treat-hiding toys, which can be used to teach you problem-solving skills and encourage independent thinking.

Treat-dispensing toys

Treat-dispensing toys are a popular choice for rewarding good behavior during training. These toys are designed to hold treats, which are released when you engage with the toy in a specific way. By using treat-dispensing toys, you not only provide a reward but also encourage active play and mental stimulation. These toys can be particularly useful in teaching commands or tricks that require specific actions.

Squeaky toys

Squeaky toys can be a great source of motivation and engagement during training sessions. The sound of a squeaky toy often captures your attention and excites you, making it an effective reward. Squeaky toys can also be used as a tool for shaping behavior, as the sound can be associated with positive reinforcement.

Tug toys

Tug toys can be a valuable asset in training sessions, especially for teaching commands like “fetch” or “drop it.” These toys encourage interaction and promote bonding between you and your trainer. Tug toys also mimic natural prey, giving you an outlet for predatory instincts during play and training.

Can I Use Toys As Rewards During Training Sessions?

Considerations for Using Toys as Rewards

Selecting the right toy

When using toys as rewards, it is important to select the right toy for the specific training task. Consider the size, durability, and functionality of the toy. Ensure that the toy is safe and appropriate for your age, breed, and size. Choose toys that are highly appealing to you and hold your interest. By selecting the right toy, you increase the effectiveness of the reward and maximize your motivation.

Toy safety

Safety should always be a top priority when using toys as rewards. Ensure that the toys you choose are made from non-toxic materials and do not pose any choking hazards. Regularly inspect the toys for wear and tear, discarding any damaged or broken toys. Additionally, supervise your playtime with toys to prevent accidents or injuries.

Avoiding toy dependency

While toys can be a valuable tool in training, it is important to avoid dependency on toys as the sole reward. Over time, you should aim to transition from toy rewards to other forms of rewards, such as verbal praise or treats. This helps prevent your training progress from stalling if toys are unavailable or not suitable for a particular training scenario.

Balancing toy rewards with other rewards

To ensure a well-rounded training experience, it is important to balance toy rewards with other forms of rewards. While toys can be highly motivating and engaging, incorporating other rewards such as verbal praise, treats, and physical affection can provide a more comprehensive reinforcement strategy. This balance allows for greater flexibility in training and promotes a positive and diverse training environment.

Training Techniques Using Toys

Clicker training

Clicker training is a training technique that utilizes a clicker, a small handheld device that emits a distinct clicking sound. This sound serves as a marker to indicate the exact moment when you have performed the desired behavior. By pairing the click with a toy reward, you create a strong association between the click, the behavior, and the reward. Clicker training can be highly effective in shaping new behaviors and strengthening existing ones.

Toy retrieval exercises

Toy retrieval exercises involve teaching you to fetch and retrieve a specific toy upon command. This exercise not only stimulates physical activity but also reinforces obedience and responsiveness. By incorporating toy retrieval exercises into your training routine, you can improve your focus, agility, and recall skills.

Toy as a target

Using a toy as a target is a technique that involves teaching you to touch or interact with a specific toy upon command. This skill is particularly useful for teaching tricks or commands that require a physical interaction with an object. By using the toy as a target, you create a clear and tangible goal for yourself, creating a sense of achievement when successfully completing the task.

Teaching tricks and commands with toys

Toys can be instrumental in teaching a wide range of tricks and commands. The playful nature of toys makes learning more enjoyable and less intimidating. Whether it’s teaching you to sit, stay, or perform intricate tricks, incorporating toys into the training process can make the learning experience more interactive and rewarding.

Can I Use Toys As Rewards During Training Sessions?

Introducing Toys as Rewards in Training

Start with positive association

To introduce toys as rewards in training, it is essential to start with a positive association. Present the toy in a calm and friendly manner, allowing you to explore the toy at your own pace. Pair the introduction of the toy with verbal praise and treats to create a positive experience. By associating the toy with positive emotions from the beginning, you set the stage for a successful training partnership.

Gradual integration into training sessions

Once you have established a positive association with the toy, gradually integrate it into your training sessions. Start by using the toy as a reward for simple commands or tricks. As you progress, increase the complexity of the tasks and the duration of training sessions. This gradual integration allows you to build a stronger bond with the toy and reinforces the positive association between the toy and successful training outcomes.

Pairing toys with verbal praise and treats

To maximize the effectiveness of toy rewards, pair them with verbal praise and treats. This combination creates a multi-sensory experience that further reinforces the desired behavior. Verbal praise provides immediate feedback and encouragement, while treats offer a tangible and delicious reward. By combining these elements with the toy reward, you create a powerful and comprehensive reinforcement strategy.

Progressive increase in toy rewards

As you become more proficient in your training, gradually increase the use of toy rewards. Start by using toys as occasional rewards, gradually transitioning to more frequent and varied use. This progressive increase ensures that the toy remains highly motivating and prevents you from becoming desensitized to its rewards. It also allows for a natural progression in your training journey, challenging you to continually improve and achieve new goals.

Alternatives to Toy Rewards

Verbal praise

Verbal praise is a simple yet powerful alternative to toy rewards. Utilizing positive and enthusiastic verbal cues such as “good job” or “well done” can be highly motivating and encouraging. Verbal praise helps reinforce positive behaviors and creates a strong bond between you and your trainer or owner.

Treat rewards

Treat rewards are a classic and effective alternative to toy rewards. Treats can be used as a standalone reward or paired with verbal praise. Choose treats that are high in value and appealing to you. By using treats as rewards, you can reinforce behaviors and achieve training goals through positive reinforcement.

Physical affection

Physical affection, such as petting, cuddling, or gentle strokes, can be a rewarding alternative to toy rewards. This form of reward strengthens the emotional bond between you and your trainer or owner. Physical affection also creates a sense of comfort and security, contributing to a positive training experience.

Playtime interactions

Playtime interactions serve as a fun and engaging alternative to toy rewards. Engaging in interactive play sessions, such as fetch or hide-and-seek, provides mental and physical stimulation while reinforcing positive behaviors. Incorporate playtime interactions into your training routine to create a dynamic and enjoyable training experience.

Can I Use Toys As Rewards During Training Sessions?

Overcoming Challenges with Toy Rewards

Managing toy possessiveness

One challenge that may arise when using toys as rewards is toy possessiveness. Some dogs may become overly protective of their toys, leading to possessive behavior during training sessions. To overcome this challenge, establish clear boundaries and rules regarding toy possession. Use command cues and time limits to indicate when it is appropriate to interact with the toy. Consistency and positive reinforcement can help address and manage toy possessiveness effectively.

Dealing with distractions during training

Distractions can pose a challenge during training sessions when using toys as rewards. Your attention may be diverted by other stimuli, leading to a lack of focus and reduced training effectiveness. To overcome this challenge, gradually increase the level of distractions during training sessions. Start in a controlled environment and gradually add more stimulating elements. Use toys as rewards to redirect your attention back to the training tasks and reinforce your focus.

Addressing overexcitement and lack of focus

Overexcitement and lack of focus can hinder the training process when using toys as rewards. Some dogs may become overly excited or easily distracted by the presence of toys, making it challenging to maintain focus. To address this, practice impulse control exercises outside of training sessions. Teach commands like “wait” or “leave it” to establish self-control. Incorporate toys as rewards only when you have successfully demonstrated focus and calmness, gradually increasing the criteria over time.

Modifying toys for specific training needs

In some cases, you may need to modify toys to suit specific training needs. For example, you can attach a rope or string to a small toy to facilitate retrieval exercises. You may also need to add extra padding or layers to a toy to make it suitable for games that involve biting or tugging. Modifying toys can help tailor the reward to the specific training task, making it more effective and enjoyable for you.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

Using toys as the sole reward

One common mistake to avoid when using toys as rewards is relying solely on toys for reinforcement. While toys can be highly motivating, they should be used in conjunction with other forms of rewards, such as verbal praise and treats. Over time, aim to reduce the dependence on toys and transition to other rewards, ensuring a comprehensive and balanced training approach.

Neglecting training without toys

Another mistake to avoid is neglecting training sessions that do not involve toys. While toys can be highly engaging, it is important to practice training exercises without relying on toys as rewards. This helps ensure that you can perform commands and tricks in various scenarios, even when toys are not available. Train regularly without toys to strengthen your skills and promote generalization of behaviors.

Using inappropriate toys

Using inappropriate toys as rewards is also a mistake to avoid. Ensure that the toys you choose are suitable for your age, size, and breed. Avoid toys that can be easily destroyed or pose a choking hazard. Inappropriate toys can hinder the training process and potentially lead to injuries or accidents. Always prioritize safety and choose toys that are appropriate for your training needs.

Failing to establish clear boundaries with toy rewards

Failing to establish clear boundaries with toy rewards can create confusion and inconsistent training outcomes. Clearly define the rules regarding toy possession, use, and access. Use specific command cues to indicate when it is appropriate to interact with the toy. By establishing clear boundaries, you promote a structured and effective training environment.

When Using Toys as Rewards Is Not Suitable

Fear or anxiety-based training

Using toys as rewards may not be suitable in training scenarios involving fear or anxiety-based behaviors. Fearful or anxious dogs may associate the toy reward with negative emotions, exacerbating their anxiety. In such cases, it is important to prioritize desensitization and counterconditioning techniques to address the underlying fear or anxiety before incorporating toys as rewards.

Destructive chewing behavior

If your dog has a history of destructive chewing behavior, using toys as rewards may not be suitable. Offering toys as rewards may inadvertently reinforce the destructive chewing behavior, as your dog may associate the toy with the act of chewing. Instead, focus on redirecting the chewing behavior to appropriate chew toys and gradually incorporate appropriate toy rewards once the destructive chewing behavior is under control.

Aggression or possessiveness towards toys

Using toys as rewards may not be suitable if your dog exhibits aggression or possessiveness towards toys. Aggression or possessiveness can pose a safety risk during training sessions. Address and manage these behavioral issues with the help of a professional trainer or behaviorist before introducing toys as rewards.

Medical conditions or restrictions

Lastly, if your dog has any medical conditions or restrictions that prevent them from actively engaging with toys, using toys as rewards may not be suitable. It is important to prioritize your dog’s health and safety above all else. Consult with your veterinarian for appropriate alternative rewards that are compatible with your dog’s medical needs.


Using toys as rewards in training sessions can offer numerous benefits, including increased motivation, enhanced focus, positive association, and variety. By selecting suitable toys, considering important factors such as toy safety and avoiding dependency on toys, you can effectively integrate toy rewards into your training routine. Explore various training techniques that incorporate toys, and gradually introduce toys as rewards in a positive and progressive manner. However, it is important to consider alternatives to toy rewards, overcome challenges, and avoid common mistakes. Be mindful of situations where using toys as rewards may not be suitable, such as fear-based training or destructive chewing behavior. Remember to prioritize your dog’s well-being and tailor the training process to their individual needs. With careful consideration, appropriate use of toys as rewards can greatly enhance your training experience and strengthen your bond with your furry companion.